BCI vs GSG: Performance, Holdings, Fees & Risk
BCI and GSG are ETFs, but they can differ materially in exposure, yield, fees and risk. BCI is abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Strategy K-1 Free ETF, while GSG is iShares S&P GSCI Commodity-Indexed Trust. BCI is broader by holdings count, with 31 positions versus 24 for GSG. BCI is more concentrated at the top, based on top-10 holdings weight. Current AlgovestIQ evidence has BCI ahead on AIQ Score, 56 versus 55.
What is the main difference between BCI and GSG?
BCI and GSG have little in common: 4% of their weight is in the same securities.
| Metric | BCI | GSG |
|---|---|---|
| Fund | ||
| Expense ratio | 0.26% | 0.75% |
| Assets under management | $3.2B | $942M |
| Holdings | 31 | 24 |
| Top-10 concentration | 73.5% | 65% |
| Average volume | 1,066,445 | 1,708,954 |
| Performance | ||
| 1Y return | +8% | +46.9% |
| YTD return | +25.4% | +48% |
| 5Y annualized returnTotal return, distributions reinvested | +8.3% | +13.4% |
| Risk | ||
| Annualized volatility | 22.6% | 26.1% |
| Max drawdown (1Y) | -16.3% | -18.8% |
| Max drawdown (5Y)Total return, distributions reinvested | -26.4% | -29.1% |
| Beta | -0.21 | -0.64 |
| Sharpe ratio | 0.30 | 1.47 |
| Sortino ratio | 0.36 | 2.16 |
| AlgovestIQ | ||
| AIQ Score | 56/100 | 55/100 |
| AIQ Edge Score | 7/10 | 6/10 |
| Momentum | 41/100 | 82/100 |
| Risk Resilience | 37/100 | 13/100 |
AlgovestIQ AIQ Comparison
abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Strategy K-1 Free ETF vs iShares S&P GSCI Commodity-Indexed Trust
BCI leads
BCI leads by 1 AIQ points, primarily on Value and Risk Resilience, having only recently taken the lead back from GSG.
Fragile: 2 of 4 evidence groups support BCI, the lead recently changed hands, and its current signal state is conflicted.
abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Strategy K-1 Free ETF
iShares S&P GSCI Commodity-Indexed Trust
The Algovestiq AIQ Score currently favors BCI over GSG, 56 versus 55 as of Nov 18, 2026. BCI's advantage is driven primarily by stronger value and risk resilience, while GSG holds the stronger momentum profile. BCI also shows the stronger technical structure relative to its 50-day moving average. 2 of 4 covered evidence groups favor BCI today, and the comparison is rated Fragile on stability: the AIQ gap is narrow at 1 points. BCI lead: Reversed — GSG led by 1 AIQ points 30 sessions ago; BCI now leads by 1.
Compare abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Strategy K-1 Free ETF and iShares S&P GSCI Commodity-Indexed Trust across performance, expense ratio, dividend yield, drawdown, volatility and the Algovestiq AIQ Score.
BCI vs GSG: which fits what
Each row is settled by a single measure. Where the gap is too small to matter it reads Similar, and no row decides the comparison as a whole.
| If you want | BCI | GSG | Fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lower costExpense ratio | 0.26% | 0.75% | BCI |
| Broader diversificationNumber of holdings | 31 | 24 | BCI |
| Lower concentrationWeight of the 10 largest holdings | 73.5% | 65% | GSG |
| Smaller drawdownsMax drawdown, 5 years | -26.4% | -29.1% | BCI |
| Lower volatilityAnnualized volatility, 1 year | 22.6% | 26.1% | BCI |
Similar means the gap is within 0.01 percentage points of expense ratio, 25% more holdings, 3 points of top-10 weight, 0.2 points of yield, 2 points of drawdown or 1 point of volatility. Past drawdowns and volatility describe the funds’ history, not their future.
Performance over time
Total return with distributions reinvested, from daily closes for both ETFs.
Total return comparison
Growth of $10,000, distributions reinvested
Split-adjusted closes; each distribution is reinvested at the close on its ex-dividend date. Taxes and trading costs are not modeled.
Compare BCI and GSG against another ticker
Open a multi-ticker workspace without changing this focused pair page.
AIQ Factor Divergence
Where the two separate, on the four dimensions behind the AIQ Score. Bars read outward from a shared zero: further from the centre is a wider gap.
- Value88 vs 26BCI +62
- Momentum41 vs 82GSG +41
- Risk Resilience37 vs 13BCI +24
- Quality63 vs 64Even
2 of 4 evidence groups favor BCI. BCI’s edge is concentrated in value and risk resilience; GSG keeps a meaningful momentum edge.
What changed since the last close
Latest scored session 2026-11-18, compared against the prior scored session 2026-11-17.
Largest factor move: Value +2
New signals
- Drawdown Recovery Signal — bullish, risk_regime, long horizon (-9.0%)
- RSI Oversold — bullish, momentum, short horizon
Largest factor move: Momentum +9
No signal started or stopped since the prior session; its 4 active signals are unchanged.
BCI's lead narrowed by 2 AIQ points in the latest session.
Deeper signal detail for each name lives on its own signals page — BCI and GSG both carry a full feed there.
The central trade-off
BCI (abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Strategy K-1 Free ETF): the stronger current systematic profile, led by value and risk resilience.
GSG (iShares S&P GSCI Commodity-Indexed Trust): the counter-case, on momentum, technicals — but at materially higher volatility, 23.2% against 12.3%.
Fund facts, side by side
Two funds tracking overlapping universes are separated by cost and risk far more than by holdings. Those lead here.
| Measure | BCI | GSG | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.26% | 0.75% | Lower is better — it compounds against you every year you hold. |
| Assets under management | $3.2B | $942M | Larger funds generally carry tighter spreads. |
| Holdings | 31 | 24 | More holdings means broader diversification, not better returns. |
| Average volume | 1,066,445 | 1,708,954 | Liquidity — matters most if you trade size. |
| Annualized volatility | 22.6% | 26.1% | Lower is a steadier ride for the same exposure. |
| Max drawdown (1Y) | -16.3% | -18.8% | The worst peak-to-trough loss over the past year. |
| Sharpe ratio | 0.30 | 1.47 | Return per unit of risk. Higher is better. |
| Beta | -0.21 | -0.64 | Sensitivity to the broad market. Neither direction is better — it depends on the role in your portfolio. |
Where the exposure actually sits
Sector exposure for each fund, ordered by the size of the difference.
How much of the same holdings they own
BCI and GSG share 4.24% of their weighted exposure across 2 common holdings.
28 holdings are unique to BCI, and 21 holdings are unique to GSG. Owning both is genuinely additive — most of the capital sits in different securities.
BCI is the more concentrated of the two: its ten largest positions are 73.53% of the fund, against 65% for GSG (31 holdings vs 24). Concentration cuts both ways — it is what drives outperformance when the top names work, and what makes the drawdown deeper when they do not.
Largest shared positions
| Holding | BCI | GSG | Shared |
|---|---|---|---|
| TREASURY BILL | 2.5% | 5.55% | 2.5% |
| TREASURY BILL | 1.74% | 5.05% | 1.74% |
Shared weight is the lower of the two positions — the portion of capital both funds genuinely have in the same security.
What BCI adds that GSG doesn’t
| Holding | BCI | GSG |
|---|---|---|
| SSC GOVERNMENT MM GVMXX | 41.26% | Not held |
| GOLD 100 OZ FUTR FEB27 XCEC 20270224 | 5.6% | Not held |
| BRENT CRUDE FUTR MAR27 IFEU 20270129 | 5.42% | Not held |
| WTI CRUDE FUTURE JAN27 XNYM 20261221 | 4.44% | Not held |
| NATURAL GAS FUTR JAN27 XNYM 20261229 | 3.81% | Not held |
| COPPER FUTURE MAR27 XCEC 20270329 | 2.87% | Not held |
What GSG adds that BCI doesn’t
| Holding | GSG | BCI |
|---|---|---|
| TREASURY BILL | 10.65% | Not held |
| TREASURY BILL | 8.17% | Not held |
| TREASURY BILL | 7.47% | Not held |
| TREASURY BILL | 6.39% | Not held |
| TREASURY BILL | 6.33% | Not held |
| TREASURY BILL | 5.55% | 2.5% |
Each list is a fund’s largest positions by weight that the other fund does not hold, or holds at less than half the weight.
AIQ Agreement Matrix
2 of 4 covered evidence groups favor BCI. A wide gap backed by one group is a weaker case than a narrow gap backed by five.
| Evidence group | Favors | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| AIQ Score | Even | 56 vs 55 |
| Fundamentals | Not covered | Not covered |
| Valuation | BCI | Value 88 vs 26 |
| Technicals | GSG | Price vs 50-day -9.1% vs -9.6%; vs 200-day 0.9% vs 6.3% |
| Risk Resilience | BCI | Risk Resilience 37 vs 13 |
| Analyst expectations | Not covered | Not covered |
✓ agrees with the overall verdict · ✕ points the other way. Groups marked “not covered” lack data on one or both of BCI and GSG and are excluded from the count.
AIQ Decision Stability
The conclusion is sensitive to small changes. Treat the lead as provisional and watch the flip conditions below.
- The AIQ gap is narrow at 1 points. (argues the conclusion is provisional)
- Only 2 of 4 covered evidence groups agree. (argues the conclusion is provisional)
- The lead has already changed hands inside the comparison window. (argues the conclusion is provisional)
- The lead has been steady session to session. (supports the conclusion holding)
- The leader is throwing conflicting signals. (argues the conclusion is provisional)
Stability combines the score gap, how broadly the evidence agrees, how steady the lead has been across daily snapshots, the current signal state on both names, and analyst dispersion on BCI.
How the comparison changed
120 daily snapshots · Jun 1 – Nov 18BCI lead: Reversed — GSG led by 1 AIQ points 30 sessions ago; BCI now leads by 1.
- Today
- BCI +1
- 56 vs 55
- 7 sessions ago
- GSG +2
- 56 vs 58
- 30 sessions ago
- GSG +1
- 56 vs 57
- 90 sessions ago
- BCI +8
- 53 vs 45
The lead changed hands 8 times in this window, most recently on Nov 12 when BCI moved ahead of GSG.
AIQ Signal Divergence
Only the signals that bear on the head-to-head. A conflicted name is carrying bullish and bearish rules at the same time — the technical evidence is not pointing one way.
3 bullish / 1 bearish / 2 neutral, conflicted
Only BCI
- ATR Contraction - Coiling — neutral, volatility, short horizon (1.23%)
- RSI Oversold — bullish, momentum, short horizon
2 bullish / 1 bearish / 1 neutral, conflicted
No signal that the other name lacks.
Both carry 4 more signals that do not separate them: Golden Cross Active, ADX Trend Strengthening, Drawdown Recovery Signal, Keltner Channel Breakdown.
BCI leads the comparison while carrying a conflicted signal state, which is one reason the stability rating is not higher.
Price vs model alignment
Whether the latest session's price move confirms what the model did over the same session, or contradicts it.
Price is down while the AIQ Score moved up 1 points over the same session — price and model disagree (price -2.08%, AIQ +1 points).
Price is down while the AIQ Score moved up 3 points over the same session — price and model disagree (price -2.14%, AIQ +3 points).
What would flip this result
A state, not a forecast. These are the specific, observable changes that would reverse the verdict — not a price prediction.
- 1GSG closes the Value gap — currently 62 points behind, the largest single contributor to BCI's edge.
- 2GSG's Keltner Channel Breakdown resolves — a bearish volatility rule currently active against it.
- 3BCI's conflicting signal state resolves bearish — it currently carries 3 bullish and 1 bearish rules at once.
- 4A market regime shift would change the factor readings behind both scores; a rotation toward or away from quality, value or momentum could move the result.
The full evidence
Every number behind the verdict. The leader is called above each group so you are not left to solve it from the table.
Fundamentals
Split| Metric | BCI | GSG |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin | — | 100% |
| Operating margin | — | 79.2% |
| Return on equity (TTM) | — | 24.5% |
| Debt to equity | — | 0 |
Performance
GSG leads 4 of 6 windows| Metric | BCI | GSG |
|---|---|---|
| 1 week (5 sessions) | -0.6% | -1% |
| 1 month (20 sessions) | -7.3% | -8.1% |
| 3 months (63 sessions) | -1.8% | 3.1% |
| 6 months (126 sessions) | -3.4% | -0.2% |
| Year to date | 25.4% | 48% |
| 1 year (252 sessions) | 8% | 46.9% |
Technicals
GSG has the stronger structure| Metric | BCI | GSG |
|---|---|---|
| RSI (14) | 29.3 | 36.3 |
| ADX (14) | 35.5 | 30.3 |
| Price vs 50-day | -9.1% | -9.6% |
| Price vs 200-day | 0.9% | 6.3% |
| Volatility (1M, annualized) | 12.3% | 23.2% |
Risk
BCI is the more resilient| Metric | BCI | GSG |
|---|---|---|
| Beta | -0.21 | -0.64 |
| Sharpe ratio | 0.3 | 1.47 |
| Sortino ratio | 0.36 | 2.16 |
| Max drawdown | -16.3% | -18.8% |
| Current drawdown | -8.6% | -9.5% |
| Annualized volatility | 22.6% | 26.1% |
| Value at risk (95%) | -1.9% | -2.4% |
Straight answers
Short answers to the questions fund investors ask about this pair, from the figures above.
What is the difference between BCI and GSG?
BCI and GSG have little in common: 4% of their weight is in the same securities.
How much do BCI and GSG overlap?
BCI and GSG share 4.24% of their weighted exposure across 2 common holdings. 28 holdings are unique to BCI, and 21 holdings are unique to GSG. Owning both is genuinely additive — most of the capital sits in different securities.
Which ETF is more diversified, BCI or GSG?
BCI holds more positions: 31 versus 24 for GSG.
Which has the lower expense ratio?
BCI has the lower expense ratio, 0.26% a year against 0.75% for GSG.
Which ETF has been more volatile?
GSG has been more volatile over the past year, at 26.1% annualized against 22.6% for BCI.
Which ETF has had the smaller drawdown?
BCI fell less from peak to trough over the past five years: -26.4% against -29.1% for GSG.
Compare BCI and GSG with others
Continue your research
This page answers which of the two. These answer the questions on either side of it.
How this comparison is scored
The Algovestiq AIQ Score composites four factors — Quality, Value, Momentum and Risk, each carrying a fixed weight. Sentiment is reported separately as SentimentPulse and is not folded into the composite. Scores refresh every trading day, and this page regenerates from the latest snapshot rather than being written once.
The verdict names a leader, states how broadly six independent evidence groups agree, and rates how durable that conclusion is given the score gap, its recent trajectory and the current signal state on both names.
How to use side-by-side comparison →This comparison is informational and educational, not investment advice. AIQ scores update daily; re-check after earnings, guidance or macro data that materially changes either name’s factor profile.